Lie of Sight

The Hallway Daily find-the-liar puzzle #17 · Oct 5, 2026

Who tracked mud up the stairs?

Free to play. Every past daily is free, back to Daily #1.

Play Daily #17

About this case

Daily #17 takes you into the hallway, a 6 × 4 board with three short walls inside. Everyone passes through the hallway, so it sees all the comings and goings, and all the mud. It’s the first daily set here. Dad, the Kid, Grandma and Rex were all there, and one of them is fibbing. Everyone wants to know: Who tracked mud up the stairs? What they say is about the rain boots and the plant, and about each other. Try them in different squares of the hallway until only one story can’t be made to fit.

Date
Monday, October 5, 2026
Board
6 × 4 squares
Walls inside
3
Witnesses
4

In the room

  • Coat rack tall
  • Rain boots flat
  • Plant tall
  • Rug flat
  • Bench low
  • Ball flat

Tall here: the coat rack and the plant. Tall things block every view, though not Rex’s nose. Low: the bench. Only the Kid’s view stops at a low thing; the grown-ups see right over. The rain boots, the rug and the ball lie flat: everyone sees straight past. The room isn’t a plain rectangle: one of the board’s 24 squares is cut away.

How they see in here

  • Dad sees his whole row and column, 6 squares across and 4 down, until a wall or something tall gets in the way.

  • The Kid sees his row and column too, but he’s short, so the low things in here stop him as well as the tall ones.

  • Grandma is nearsighted: two squares along each of her eight directions and no further, anywhere in the hallway.

  • Rex sniffs rather than looks, and only the eight squares touching his own; not even a wall stops his nose.

Every rule, with pictures, is in How to play.

A tip for this room

Start with the tightest story. Grandma sees only two squares each way, so anything she saw was close to her.

How everyone did

40 detectives finished Daily #17.

Caught the liar first try
98%
Solved it
98%
Middle time
1:05

Counted from everyone’s first try, once 20 have finished; never a name or anyone’s own time.

No spoilers here. This page never shows who lied or where anyone stood. Stuck? Read how to catch the liar.

New to liar puzzles? How to find the liar

All past dailies