Lie of Sight

Einstein’s riddle: who owns the fish?

Einstein’s riddle is a logic puzzle about five houses in a row. Each house has its own color, and the person in it has their own nationality, pet, drink and brand of cigarette. Fifteen clues link them, and you have to work out who owns the fish. Below is the puzzle in plain words and a solution in nine steps, with a grid after the big ones. After that come the 1962 original, the zebra puzzle, which has a different answer, and what is known about where it comes from.

Jump to the answer

Play today’s case

The puzzle

Five houses stand in a row, numbered 1 to 5 from left to right. Each is painted a different color. In each lives one person of a different nationality, who keeps a different pet, drinks something different and smokes a different brand of cigarette.

  1. The Brit lives in the red house.
  2. The Swede keeps dogs.
  3. The Dane drinks tea.
  4. The green house is just to the left of the white house, its next-door neighbor.
  5. The person in the green house drinks coffee.
  6. The Pall Mall smoker keeps birds.
  7. The person in the yellow house smokes Dunhill.
  8. The person in the middle house, house 3, drinks milk.
  9. The Norwegian lives in the first house, house 1.
  10. The Blends smoker lives next door to the one who keeps cats.
  11. The one who keeps horses lives next door to the Dunhill smoker.
  12. The Blue Master smoker drinks beer.
  13. The German smokes Prince.
  14. The Norwegian lives next door to the blue house.
  15. The Blends smoker lives next door to the one who drinks water.

Who owns the fish?

The fish appears in none of the clues: you find it by ruling out everything else. Want to try it yourself first? Stop here, draw the grid below on paper, and come back when you are stuck.

Both versions name real cigarette brands, and we keep them so you can match your copy line by line.

Before you start: draw a grid

Five houses and five lists make 25 things to place, far too many to hold in your head. So draw a grid: a column for each house and a row for each list. Every time you are sure of something, write it in.

Two rules do a lot of quiet work. Each list has every value exactly once, so when four houses have a drink, the fifth gets the one that is left. And “to the left” means on your left as you look at the row, so house 1 is just to the left of house 2.

The empty grid: a column for each house, a row for each list. Blank squares: not known yet.
House12345
Color
Who
Drink
Smokes
Pet
The empty grid: a column for each house, a row for each list. Blank squares: not known yet.

The solution, step by step

Spoilers from here. Each step uses only the clues and the facts before it, and says which clue it uses. The grids show what is settled so far.

Step 1: Start with the fixed points

Two clues put something in a numbered house outright. The Norwegian lives in house 1 (clue 9), and the person in house 3 drinks milk (clue 8). Write both in.

Step 2: The blue house

The Norwegian lives next door to the blue house (clue 14). House 1 has only one neighbor, house 2, so house 2 is blue.

Step 3: Green and white

The green house is just to the left of the white one, its next-door neighbor (clue 4), so they are a side-by-side pair. House 2 is blue, so the pair can’t use house 2: it is houses 3 and 4, or houses 4 and 5.

The person in the green house drinks coffee (clue 5), but house 3 drinks milk, so green isn’t house 3. Green is house 4, white is house 5, and house 4 drinks coffee.

The grid after step 3. New squares are shaded. Blank squares: not known yet.
House12345
ColorBlueGreenWhite
WhoNorwegian
DrinkMilkCoffee
Smokes
Pet
The grid after step 3. New squares are shaded. Blank squares: not known yet.

Step 4: Red and yellow

Red and yellow are left for houses 1 and 3. The Brit lives in the red house (clue 1), and house 1 is the Norwegian’s, so red is house 3, with the Brit in it, and house 1 is yellow.

Step 5: Dunhill, and horses next door

The person in the yellow house smokes Dunhill (clue 7), so house 1 smokes Dunhill. The horses live next door to the Dunhill smoker (clue 11), and house 1’s only neighbor is house 2, so the horses are in house 2.

Step 6: What the Norwegian drinks

Go through the drinks for house 1. Not milk: that’s house 3. Not coffee: that’s house 4. Not tea: that’s the Dane’s (clue 3), and house 1 is the Norwegian’s. Not beer: that goes with Blue Master (clue 12), and house 1 smokes Dunhill. Only water is left.

The grid after step 6. New squares are shaded. Blank squares: not known yet.
House12345
ColorYellowBlueRedGreenWhite
WhoNorwegianBrit
DrinkWaterMilkCoffee
SmokesDunhill
PetHorses
The grid after step 6. New squares are shaded. Blank squares: not known yet.

Step 7: Blends, tea and the Dane

The Blends smoker lives next door to the one who drinks water (clue 15). Water is house 1, so Blends is smoked in house 2.

Tea and beer are left for houses 2 and 5. Beer goes with Blue Master (clue 12), and house 2 smokes Blends, so house 2 drinks tea, and house 5 drinks beer and smokes Blue Master. Tea is the Dane’s drink (clue 3), so the Dane lives in house 2.

Step 8: The German and the Swede

The German and the Swede are left for houses 4 and 5. The German smokes Prince (clue 13), and house 5 smokes Blue Master, so the German lives in house 4 and smokes Prince there. The Swede lives in house 5, with the dogs (clue 2).

One brand is left, Pall Mall, for house 3, and the Pall Mall smoker keeps birds (clue 6), so the birds are in house 3.

The grid after step 8. New squares are shaded. Blank squares: not known yet.
House12345
ColorYellowBlueRedGreenWhite
WhoNorwegianDaneBritGermanSwede
DrinkWaterTeaMilkCoffeeBeer
SmokesDunhillBlendsPall MallPrinceBlue Master
PetHorsesBirdsDogs
The grid after step 8. New squares are shaded. Blank squares: not known yet.

Step 9: The cats and the fish

The cats live next door to the Blends smoker in house 2 (clue 10), so in house 1 or house 3. House 3 has the birds, so the cats are in house 1. One pet is left, and one house without one: the fish lives in house 4, with the German.

The grid, solved.
House12345
ColorYellowBlueRedGreenWhite
WhoNorwegianDaneBritGermanSwede
DrinkWaterTeaMilkCoffeeBeer
SmokesDunhillBlendsPall MallPrinceBlue Master
PetCatsHorsesBirdsFishDogs
The grid, solved.

The answer

The German owns the fish. He lives in house 4, the green house, and the Norwegian in house 1 drinks water.

Read the last grid once more against the fifteen clues: every one holds. And it is the only arrangement that does. We checked by computer, trying every way the five lists could be arranged: exactly one fits all fifteen clues. One clue is spare. Leave out clue 15 and the same arrangement is still the only one that fits; it just makes step 7 quicker. Leave out any other clue, and more than one would fit.

Notice what did the work. Two fixed points (house 1 and house 3), clues about next-door neighbors, and lists that fill themselves in once four of their five are placed. Those are the same moves that solve almost every logic grid puzzle.

The original: Life International, 1962 (the zebra puzzle)

The fish puzzle is a retelling. The earliest known version appeared in Life International magazine on December 17, 1962, and is often called the zebra puzzle, after its second question. It ran to fifteen statements, the first simply “There are five houses”. Here they are in our words, numbered the same way:

  1. There are five houses.
  2. The Englishman lives in the red house.
  3. The Spaniard has a dog.
  4. The person in the green house drinks coffee.
  5. The Ukrainian drinks tea.
  6. The green house is just to the right of the ivory house, its next-door neighbor.
  7. The Old Gold smoker keeps snails.
  8. Kools are smoked in the yellow house.
  9. The person in the middle house, house 3, drinks milk.
  10. The Norwegian lives in the first house, house 1.
  11. The Chesterfield smoker lives next door to the house with the fox.
  12. Kools are smoked next door to the house with the horse.
  13. The Lucky Strike smoker drinks orange juice.
  14. The Japanese smokes Parliaments.
  15. The Norwegian lives next door to the blue house.

Who drinks water? Who owns the zebra?

Its answer: The Norwegian drinks water, and the Japanese owns the zebra.

What changed

  • The people, drinks, pets and brands. The Englishman, Spaniard, Ukrainian and Japanese became the Brit, Swede, Dane and German, orange juice became beer, the ivory house became white, and the dog, snails, fox, horse and zebra became dogs, birds, cats, horses and fish.
  • Left and right swapped. In 1962 the green house is just to the right of the ivory one. In the fish version it is just to the left of the white one.
  • One clue more. The fish version adds clue 15, about the Blends smoker’s neighbor, the one it can do without.
  • So the answer moved. The fish ends up in house 4, while the 1962 zebra is in house 5. The Norwegian drinks water in both.
The 1962 puzzle, solved in nine steps

Step 1: Start with the fixed points

Two clues put something in a numbered house outright. The Norwegian lives in house 1 (clue 10), and the person in house 3 drinks milk (clue 9). Write both in.

Step 2: The blue house

The Norwegian lives next door to the blue house (clue 15). House 1 has only one neighbor, house 2, so house 2 is blue.

The grid after step 2. New squares are shaded. Blank squares: not known yet.
House12345
ColorBlue
WhoNorwegian
DrinkMilk
Smokes
Pet
The grid after step 2. New squares are shaded. Blank squares: not known yet.

Step 3: House 1 is yellow

The green house is just to the right of the ivory one (clue 6), so they are a side-by-side pair. House 2 is blue, so the pair can’t use house 2: it is houses 3 and 4, or houses 4 and 5.

The red house belongs to the Englishman (clue 2), and house 1 is the Norwegian’s, so house 1 isn’t red. With the pair in 3 and 4, red and yellow are left for houses 1 and 5. With the pair in 4 and 5, they are left for houses 1 and 3. Either way, red can’t be house 1, so house 1 is yellow.

Step 4: Kools, and a horse next door

Kools are smoked in the yellow house (clue 8), so in house 1. The horse lives next door to the Kools (clue 12), and house 1’s only neighbor is house 2, so the horse is in house 2.

Step 5: What the Norwegian drinks

Go through the drinks for house 1. Not milk: that’s house 3. Not coffee: that’s the green house (clue 4), and house 1 is yellow. Not tea: that’s the Ukrainian’s (clue 5). Not orange juice: that goes with Lucky Strike (clue 13), and house 1 smokes Kools.

Only water is left. That answers the first question: the Norwegian drinks water.

The grid after step 5. New squares are shaded. Blank squares: not known yet.
House12345
ColorYellowBlue
WhoNorwegian
DrinkWaterMilk
SmokesKools
PetHorse
The grid after step 5. New squares are shaded. Blank squares: not known yet.

Step 6: Who lives in house 2

Coffee, tea and orange juice are left for houses 2, 4 and 5, and house 2 isn’t green, so it doesn’t drink coffee. Suppose it drinks orange juice. Then it smokes Lucky Strike (clue 13). Who could live there? Not the Englishman: his house is red. Not the Spaniard: he has the dog (clue 3), and house 2 has the horse. Not the Japanese: he smokes Parliaments (clue 14). That leaves the Ukrainian, but he drinks tea (clue 5), not orange juice.

So house 2 drinks tea, and since tea is the Ukrainian’s drink, the Ukrainian lives in house 2.

Step 7: Ivory and green, the right way around

Now settle the pair from step 3. Suppose ivory is house 3 and green house 4. Then red is house 5, so the Englishman lives there. Green drinks coffee, so house 5 drinks orange juice and smokes Lucky Strike. The Spaniard and the Japanese share houses 3 and 4, and Old Gold, Chesterfield and Parliament are left to smoke in houses 2, 3 and 4. The Japanese smokes Parliaments. The Spaniard can’t smoke Old Gold, because the Old Gold smoker keeps snails (clue 7) and the Spaniard has the dog. So he smokes Chesterfield, and Old Gold lands in house 2, whose pet is the horse, not snails. It breaks.

So ivory is house 4, green is house 5, and red is house 3: the Englishman lives in house 3. Green drinks coffee, so house 4 drinks orange juice, and its owner smokes Lucky Strike.

The grid after step 7. New squares are shaded. Blank squares: not known yet.
House12345
ColorYellowBlueRedIvoryGreen
WhoNorwegianUkrainianEnglishman
DrinkWaterTeaMilkOrange juiceCoffee
SmokesKoolsLucky Strike
PetHorse
The grid after step 7. New squares are shaded. Blank squares: not known yet.

Step 8: The Spaniard and the Japanese

Houses 4 and 5 are left for the Spaniard and the Japanese. The Japanese smokes Parliaments, and house 4 smokes Lucky Strike, so the Japanese lives in house 5 and smokes Parliaments there. The Spaniard lives in house 4, with his dog.

Step 9: Snails, the fox and the zebra

Old Gold and Chesterfield are left for houses 2 and 3. Old Gold comes with snails, and house 2 has the horse, so Old Gold and the snails are in house 3, and house 2 smokes Chesterfield.

The fox lives next door to the Chesterfield smoker (clue 11), so in house 1 or house 3. House 3 has the snails, so the fox is in house 1. One pet is left, and one house without one: the zebra lives in house 5.

The grid, solved.
House12345
ColorYellowBlueRedIvoryGreen
WhoNorwegianUkrainianEnglishmanSpaniardJapanese
DrinkWaterTeaMilkOrange juiceCoffee
SmokesKoolsChesterfieldOld GoldLucky StrikeParliament
PetFoxHorseSnailsDogZebra
The grid, solved.

Did Einstein really write it?

Probably not, and nobody has ever shown that he did. The earliest known printing is the 1962 zebra version above, in Life International on December 17, 1962. The issue of March 25, 1963, printed the solution and the names of several hundred readers who had solved it.

The story that Albert Einstein made it up as a boy is an urban legend, and some credit Lewis Carroll instead. There is no evidence for either. The 1962 text even names Kools, a brand first sold under that name in 1933, long after Einstein’s boyhood.

The fish version is the most passed-around retelling, and others change the names, drinks and pets again. Check which version you have before you compare answers.

Where to play puzzles like it

Our deduction puzzles page has a smaller zebra puzzle to try, four houses and two lists, beside a logic grid worked square by square and more puzzles with their answers hidden. For a whodunit in the same spirit, try the mystery logic puzzles.

If you liked the “what if” in step 7 of the 1962 solution, you will like puzzles about who is lying, where every “what if” is a guess about one person. Start with knights and knaves puzzles or truth-teller and liar puzzles.

And for a new one every day, Lie of Sight is our free daily deduction puzzle. Each case is a room seen from above, and a family each say what they saw from where they stood. Exactly one of them is lying. You place them in the room, as you placed the houses here, until every story but one fits. For classic logic grids in bulk, Puzzle Baron’s Logic Puzzles has thousands to play online.

Questions people ask

What is the answer to Einstein’s riddle?

In the version most people know, the German owns the fish. In the 1962 original, the Japanese owns the zebra. In both, the Norwegian lives in the yellow house on the far left and drinks water.

Did Albert Einstein write it?

There is no evidence he did. The earliest known printing is in Life International magazine in December 1962. The story that Einstein wrote it as a boy is an urban legend, and a credit to Lewis Carroll has no evidence behind it either.

Is Einstein’s riddle the same as the zebra puzzle?

They are two versions of one puzzle, with different clues and different answers. The zebra puzzle is the 1962 original, which asks who owns the zebra. The version most people now call Einstein’s riddle asks who owns the fish. This page solves both, and the same method works for any retelling.

How do you solve Einstein’s riddle?

Draw a grid with a column for each house and a row for each list. Fill in the clues that name a house, then the neighbors of those houses, and when you are down to two possibilities, follow one until it breaks.

Is it hard?

It takes most people a while, mostly because there is too much to hold in your head. With a grid on paper it becomes a long run of small, safe steps, and no single step is hard.

More daily puzzles from the Fibbersons

Lie of Sight is one of the family’s free daily games. The others: Rex’s Fetch, Lacey’s Web, Grandma’s Knitting, The Kid’s Treasure Map, Fibs’ Laser Chase and Dusty’s Rounds. They’re all on the game picker.

Ready for today’s case?

A new case every day. Free, with no sign-up to start.