How to spot the liar
Who is lying? In a find-the-liar puzzle like Lie of Sight, everyone says what they saw, and exactly one of them is lying. To spot the liar, look for stories that can’t all be true at the same time. Then test each one: if believing it would mean two other people are lying, it can’t be true, because only one person lies. That story belongs to the liar. Here’s the method in three steps, then a small worked example.
The idea in three steps
- Turn each story into squares.“I saw the clock” means they stood somewhere the clock was in their view. “I didn’t see Dad” means they didn’t.
- Find the clash.Look for stories that can’t all be true together, wherever people stand.
- Count the liars.Only one person lies. If believing someone means two others must be lying, the one you believed is the liar.
A worked example
Here’s a tiny room made up for this page; it isn’t one of the game’s cases. There’s a clock in the top corner and a tall bookshelf near it. Grandma stands at the top right, Dad at the bottom right, and Rex the dog could be anywhere. Here’s what they say:
Dad “I saw Rex.”
Grandma “I saw Rex.”
Rex “I smelled the clock.”
Start with the tightest story. Rex can’t see; he smells the eight squares around him. So if he smelled the clock, he was in one of the three squares beside it.
Could Dad see him there? Dad sees his whole row and column, and none of those three squares is in either. Could Grandma? She sees only two squares, and the bookshelf blocks her along the top. So no.
That’s the clash. If Rex is telling the truth, Dad and Grandma are both lying. But only one person lies, so Rex is the liar.
The tinted squares are what Dad (blue) and Grandma (purple) can see from where they stand.
In a real case
Real cases have more people and bigger rooms, but the idea is the same. Start with the fussiest stories: Grandma’s two squares and Rex’s nose pin people down fastest. A story that can’t be true anywhere in the room is your answer straight away.
For every rule and what blocks whom, see How to play.
Ready to try one yourself? Find the liar puzzles has three free mini puzzles, easy to harder, with the answers hidden, who is lying riddles has eight in words, and knights and knaves puzzles has the classic version.
Finding the liar in Murdle and Clues by Sam
In Murdle, when a mystery gives you what each suspect says, check its own rules first for who may be lying. Then suppose one suspect is the liar, treat the rest as true, and mark what that forces on the grid. A clash means you supposed wrong.
In Clues by Sam there is no liar to find: its own rules say everyone speaks the truth, even the criminals. Take every clue as a fact, and test a guess the same way before you mark it.
More like them: games like Murdle and games like Clues by Sam.
Questions people ask
Is there always exactly one liar?
Yes. Every case has exactly one liar, and enough on the board to prove it. If you can make every story but one true at the same time, you’ve found them.
Does seeing work both ways?
Not always. Dad can see Grandma from across the room while she, seeing only two squares, can’t see him.
What if I accuse the wrong person?
A wrong guess costs 250 points, and you can try again. You get up to 3 guesses, so it pays to be sure.
More daily puzzles from the Fibbersons
Lie of Sight is one of the family’s free daily games. The others: Rex’s Fetch, Lacey’s Web, Grandma’s Knitting, The Kid’s Treasure Map, Fibs’ Laser Chase and Dusty’s Rounds. They’re all on the game picker.
Ready for today’s case?
A new case every day. Free, with no sign-up to start.