Lie of Sight

Grandpa's Study Daily find-the-liar puzzle #58 · Nov 15, 2026

Who used the study plant as a hat stand?

Free to play. Every past daily is free, back to Daily #1.

Play Daily #58

About this case

Daily #58 takes you into Grandpa's Study, a 5 × 5 board with three short walls inside. Grandpa has a story for every corner of the world, and most of them start in this room. This is the sixth daily case in Grandpa's Study. Four of the Fibbersons were there: Dad, the Kid, Grandma and Rex. One of them is fibbing. The day’s question: Who used the study plant as a hat stand? Their stories turn on the globe, the vase and the plant, and on each other. Try them in different squares of Grandpa's Study until only one story can’t be made to fit.

Date
Sunday, November 15, 2026
Board
5 × 5 squares
Walls inside
3
Witnesses
4

In the room

  • Bookshelf tall
  • Clock tall
  • Desk low
  • Globe low
  • Rug flat
  • Vase low
  • Plant tall

The bookshelf, the clock and the plant are tall, so nobody sees past them, but Rex smells straight through. The desk, the globe and the vase are low: they block the Kid, who’s short, and nobody else. Flat on the floor: the rug, which blocks nobody. The room isn’t a plain rectangle: two of the board’s 25 squares are cut away.

How they see in here

  • In Grandpa's Study, Dad looks along a row of five squares and a column of five, and a wall or something tall cuts either one short.

  • The Kid is the shortest of the family: in Grandpa's Study, everything low blocks his view as well as everything tall.

  • Grandma sees two squares in every direction, diagonals too, and walls and tall things stop her.

  • Rex sniffs rather than looks, and only the eight squares touching his own; not even a wall stops his nose.

Every rule, with pictures, is in How to play.

A tip for this room

Count the walls first. Each of the three short walls in Grandpa's Study cuts a row or column in two for everyone who looks, but Rex smells straight through them.

How everyone did

58 detectives have finished Daily #58 so far.

Caught the liar first try
90%
Solved it
100%
Middle time
1:10

Counted from everyone’s first try, once 20 have finished; never a name or anyone’s own time.

No spoilers here. This page never shows who lied or where anyone stood. Stuck? Read how to catch the liar.

New to liar puzzles? How to find the liar

All past dailies